Showing posts with label Veronica Roth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Veronica Roth. Show all posts

Friday, May 25, 2018

REVIEW: DIVERGENT SERIES 3 - ALLEGIANT ~ VERONICA ROTH

It’s been quite a while since I finished Allegiant by Veronica Roth, but truthfully I was so completely underwhelmed and disappointed that I could not be bothered to write a review.  Allegiant commences where Insurgent left off.  Tris and co, not satisfied with the new status quo, joins the rebellion and sets off to discover what lies beyond the boundaries.  They discover that their city is embroiled in an experiment conducted by the Bureau of Genetic Welfare.  Following the Purity war which resulted from attempts to genetically remove negative behaviors from societies, the Bureau was founded to use selective breeding to repair the genetic damage they caused, over several generations by forcibly isolating several populations, including Tris’ home.  These populations were organised into factions to better monitor certain behavioural traits.  The divergents turn out to be genetically pure individuals whose DNA shows none of the genetic damage caused by previous genetic tampering.  The divergent’s importance was however vastly overstated in the video made by Edith Prior (an indication that Roth had no idea how she wanted to end the series at the time she wrote Insurgent).  Tris, Tobias and friends ultimately discover more secrecy and manipulation by the Bureau and take it upon themselves to right to wrongs of past and present.
 
Sadly, this was a very disappointing conclusion to the Divergent trilogy.  It felt like completely different authors had written Divergent, Insurgent and Allegiant.  The author just didn’t have the same voice.  It felt like the Roth had no idea how she wanted to end the series and ultimately just grabbed at straws and rushed to release the final product. 
Tris dying felt absolutely unnecessary – and I don’t say this simply because her death disappointed me.  I truly don’t see why she had to die.  It makes no sense and in no way enhances the story.  It felt… superfluous.  It felt like Roth threw it in there for shock value.  She wanted Tris to sacrifice herself for the greater good (I suppose this was meant to be ironic since Tris had finally decided that she didn’t want to die), but then she needed a much better crafted storyline to justify it; because it fell flat.  When a character death falls flat, it’s a massive disservice to that character and the audience.  Tris deserved a better ending, or at least a better death - something vital.  Uriah’s death upset me more than Tris’ death did because (he was a favourite of mine, yes, but more than that) it was relevant and believable and necessary for the plot. Tris death was none of those things. 
Movie poster
I was curious as to how the movie would portray the events and watched it the very evening I finished the book.  If 10% of the movie is based on the book, it’s a lot.  They made massive, massive changes; the largest of which is having Tris survive.  Granted, at the time they were planning another sequel (which is also evident by the ending), but while the movie is in no way a masterpiece, it is a vast improvement from the book.  Either way I’m sad to say that while Divergent was thrilling and Insurgent was entertaining, completing the Divergent trilogy now feels like a complete waste of my time (too much time and energy I’ll never get back) and the utter disappointment that is Allegiant will prevent me from recommending this series to those who have not yet experienced it. 
 
Product Information:

 
Title: Allegiant
Series: Divergent (not standalone)
Author: Veronica Roth
Publisher: Harper Collins Children's Books
Year: 2013
Pages: 545

ISBN-10: 0062420097ISBN-13: 978-0062420091
ASIN: B00BKZUVGM
 

Related posts:




Thursday, January 11, 2018

REVIEW: DIVERGENT SERIES 2 - INSURGENT ~ VERONICA ROTH


Veronica Roth’s Insurgent is the second book in the Divergent series and picks up where it’s predecessor, Divergent, left off; Tris, Tobias, Caleb, Marcus and Peter fleeing the aftermath of the Abnegation attack, on the train, out of the city.  Along their journey they attempt to rejoin the remaining loyal Dauntless and seek safe haven with other factions, but with Erudite and the rebel Dauntless out for blood, allies are few and far between. 
 
 
Tris’ guilt over her parents’ deaths and killing Will is pulling her into a darkness she has not known before and Tris finds herself having a bit of a death wish, placing extreme pressure on her relationship with Tobias.  
 
Shailene Woodley nails this heartbreaking scene in the film
 
With major secrets and tension between them, and Tris and Tobias find their still fragile relationship on very shaky ground.  While navigating troubles of their own, they must unravel the more important mystery of why Abnegation was attacked in the first place and why Jeanine Mason is dead-set on identifying all the divergents.  Danger and mystery abound, friend and foe is indistinguishable.  A surprise return, a shocking betrayal and an unexpected ally are just some of the things keeping the reader off balance, and the unpredictable journey Tris takes the reader on makes Insurgent a very satisfying continuation of the series. 



Shortly after finishing Divergent, I innocently and accidentally came across a major Allegiant spoiler on Pinterest, which unfortunately doused my interest in continuing the series.  My delay in continuing the series therefore had nothing to do with my enjoyment thereof, or the quality of Roth’s work.  Time and distance has reawakened my curiosity and I am finally ready to see how Tris’ journey reaches its inevitable conclusion.  I very much enjoyed the action and adventure Insurgent provides, and I think the series is playing out very cleverly.  While in Divergent I admired Tris’ bravery, I found myself frustrated with her in Insurgent.  I had a hard time understanding why she made some of the decisions she did.  I absolutely respect the fact that she has lost both her parents and that the uncertainty of her current situation must be overwhelming, yet I found Tris making (in my opinion) very stupid choices in this book. 
 
Tris cuts her hair in mourning
 
I believe Roth wanted to illustrate Tris’ death wish, in which she succeeded, but the problem is that Tris’ rash behaviour placed not only herself in danger, but those around her as well, and this disregard for the safety of others is very unlike Tris.  Lying, keeping secrets and breaking promises also come much too easy.  More than once I also felt that Tris had zero regard for her relationship with Tobias, and she continued to make choices she knew would hurt both Tobias and their relationship, without attempting to have a mature conversation with him first. 
 
 
The thing I liked least about Insurgent is that I struggled to identify with Tris this time around.  It was easy in Divergent, but I did not connect with Tris all that well in Insurgent.   I do, however, commend Roth for her bravery in taking Tris on this emotional rollercoaster and not shying away from the darkness inside of Tris; it makes Tris’ ultimate epiphany that much more tangible and satisfying. 
 
Tobias with the Factionless
 
We do discover why Abnegation was targeted, what Tris’ parents were willing to die for (besides Tris and Caleb), and a whole new world is opened to us, ready to be discovered in Allegiant.  All in all Insurgent makes for a very satisfying read.
 
 
Product Information:
Title: Insurgent
Series: Divergent (not standalone)
Author: Veronica Roth
Publisher: Harper Collins Children's Books
Year: 2012
Pages: 545
ISBN-10: 0062024051
ISBN-13: 978-0062024053
ASIN: B0070R41G0

 
Related posts:
 

Friday, April 11, 2014

DIVERGENT


After a terrible war, the dystopic society of what we know today as Chicago is supposedly the last hub of civilisation, and is divided into five factions - each faction dedicated to the cultivation of a particular virtue they consider the one that could have prevented the war, and which will prevent future conflict.  Each faction values the opposite trait of that which they blame for causing the war in the first place: 1) Abnegation, the selfless who blame selfishness; 2) Candor, the honest who blame deceit; 3) Amity, the peaceful who blame conflict and fighting; 4) Erudite, the intelligent who blame ignorance; and 5) Dauntless, the brave who blame cowardice.

Every year the sixteen year-olds in this society must take an aptitude test determining which faction they are best suited for.  Then they must make the most important decision of their lives: will they remain with their families in the faction they were born into, or will they forsake their families and transfer to another faction?

The choosing ceremony

Divergent, based on the book of the same name by Veronica Roth, follows Beatrice Prior, an Abnegation born who never felt like she belonged.  Despite trying her hardest, being an Abnegation does not come easy.  Beatrice possesses traits completely unacceptable to the way of life of Abnegation, such as curiosity and sarcasm.  Beatrice is also very intrigued by the Dauntless faction and can't help but smile when she sees the fearless climbing poles and jumping out of trains. 

Instead of helping her to make the right choice, Beatrice's aptitude test leaves her even more confused when her results are inconclusive.  Beatrice's evaluator informs her that she is what is called a divergent, a person equally suited for more than one faction.  She deletes the computer records and leaves Beatrice with a warning to never share this information with anyone,  not even her family.  Beatrice struggles with her choice, feeling drawn to Dauntless, but knowing that abandoning her family would hurt her parents terribly.  She expects the decision is much easier for her brother, Caleb, who is a natural Abnegation; selfless to a fault.  The choosing ceremony brings the surprise of a lifetime when Caleb unexpectedly switches to Erudite.  Beatrice knows she now has no choice.  She has the perfect opportunity to prove herself a natural Abnegation – the most selfless choice of all stands before her.  Beatrice cannot let her parents lose both their children in one day; she will choose Abnegation.  However, after Beatrice has drawn blood from her hand and her palm hovers over the grey stones of Abnegation, at the last second her hand moves to the left and her blood drips on hot coals, proclaiming her Dauntless.  My favourite quote from the book was omitted from the movie:


A new life deserves a new name, and Beatrice renames herself Tris.  Once inside the compound the new initiates learn a terrifying truth: Only the top ten initiates will ultimately become Dauntless, the ten with the lowest rankings will be rejected and become factionless, rejected from society and forced to live on the street.  Tris is by far the smallest initiate, physically her chances don’t look good.  She will need to work hard and rely on all of her skills to secure a place in Dauntless. 

The initiates are welcomed into Dauntless

Being Abnegation born, members and initiates of other factions are hostile towards Tris, especially the Dauntless born.  While Tris does make some friends among the transfer initiates, she is not secure in these friendships as her new friends alternate between exploiting what they know to be her weakness (her physical strength), and deeply resenting her strength (her mental strength) and progress.  Tris soon finds herself in danger from friends and foes alike. 

When Tris' score improves significantly, she is attacked and must fight for her life.  Who hides behind the masks might surprise her

Tris forms an unlikely friendship with the transfer initiates’ instructor, Four, even though he seems to have just as much of a problem with her Abnegation roots as everyone else does. While they do seem to have a connection, Four’s behaviour is unpredictable.  When he and Tris are alone he is unguarded, compliments her and gives her advice; in front of the other initiates, though, Four seems to be harder on Tris than any of the others.    

Four watches Tris during fight training

Abnegation, despite being peaceful, neutral, and calm, has a fierce ongoing rivalry with the Erudite.  Abnegation is the faction in charge of the Government, and the Erudite, who seek power, believe that Abnegation are in fact selfish people who only provide for their own faction.  When Erudite starts releasing reports heavily critising Abnegation, Tris seems to be the only one to grasp the seriousness of the matter.  When Erudite leader, Jeanine Matthews, is regularly spotted at the Dauntless compound (responsible for the military defence), Tris starts suspecting that Erudite is planning to overthrow Government and destroy Abnegation;  But how can one lone, lowly initiate prove it?   And more importantly, how can she stop it; especially when Tris starts hearing snippets of conversations confirming that Erudite is flushing out and killing all divergents.  The question is why?  What danger do divergents pose to Erudite?  Or more appropriately, what power do divergents wield?

Kate Winslet as Jeanine Matthews; Theo James as Four/Tobias

The film version of Divergent is very true to the book.  It was skilfully done, and the casting is spot on.  Shailene Woodley is the perfect Tris Prior and Theo James does a wonderful job of bringing Tobias Eaton to life.  Their chemistry is wonderful, making Tris and Tobias’ journey all the more enjoyable to watch.  The look of the film is exactly right, pretty much what I had expected, and the Dauntless compound looks very much like it did in my head. 

Tris and Tobias' tattoos are wonderful works of art! I just wish the movie made mention of the fact that Tris' tattoo was in honour of the three members of her family that she lost when joining Dauntless.  Omitted from film, in the book Tris also gets tattoos of the symbols of Dauntless and Abnegation similar to Tobias getting all five.

As with any adaptation there are small changes, but nothing that upset me over much; expect that the character Uriah is not in the movie – he’s one of my favourites, but I think the producers wanted to avoid even the hint of a possible love triangle.  I think it’s safe to say the whole world is sick of love triangles.  There is much less violence and death in the film than there is the in book.  I was looking forward to the fight between Tris and Molly, but instead of Tris beating Molly like in the book, for some reason Molly beats Tris.  They meet again later and have a small with a small scuffle during the game of find the flag, which Tris wins.  I do appreciate that in the film Tris is the one to find the flag, where in the book Christina took it because Tris couldn’t reach it, even though Tris was responsible for their team’s win. 

Tris inside a fear simulation to test her mental strength

Another addition to the film I really enjoyed is the showdown between Tris and Jeanine Matthews in the end.  This scene is not in the book, but after seeing it on screen I wish it was.  Kate Winslet does a good job of playing the sneaky Erudite leader.


All things considered I am very happy with the film version of Divergent.  The release of the sequel, Insurgent, has been earmarked for 2015.

Related post:

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

FINAL DIVERGENT TRAILER

The new Divergent trailer has been released, and looks amazing!


Divergent is the first movie of a planned trilogy which is based on the novel of the same name by Veronica Roth.  The movie is set to be released

Previous trailers:




Related post:

Monday, August 26, 2013

DIVERGENT MOVIE TRAILER

The first full trailer for the Divergent movie premiered this weekend at the MTV Video Music Awards.




Thank you @ilfiore for sharing!

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

REVIEW: DIVERGENT ~ VERONICA ROTH

After a terrible war the dystopic society of what we know today as Chicago divided into five factions, each dedicated to the cultivation of a particular virtue they consider the one that could have prevented the war.  Each faction values the opposite trait of that which they blame for causing the war in the first place: 1) Abnegation, the selfless who blame selfishness; 2) Candor, the honest who blame deceit; 3) Amity, the peaceful who blame war and fighting for human nature's faults; 4) Erudite, the intelligent who blame ignorance; and 5) Dauntless, the brave who blame cowardice.


Every year the sixteen year-olds in this society must take an aptitude test determining which faction they are best suited for.  Then they must make the most important decision of their lives: will they remain with their families in the faction they were born into, or will they forsake their families and transfer to another faction?

For Beatrice Prior the decision is more difficult than most.  While she loves her family and respects the way of life of Abnegation, Beatrice has never felt like she truly belonged.  Selflessness had never come naturally to her, like it is supposed to.  She is naturally curious and sarcastic, totally unacceptable in Abnegation.  When Beatrice’s aptitude test is inconclusive and shows that she has equal aptitude for three factions (Abnegation, Erudite and Dauntless) Beatrice is labelled “divergent”.  The volunteer destroys Beatrice’s results and warns her to never reveal this information to anyone, not even her family, as being divergent endangers her life.  There is, however, no time for further discussion without raising suspicion and Beatrice is sent home.  Confused instead of reassured, Beatrice has less than 24 hours to make her choice.  Will she remain with her family in Abnegation, or will she transfer; either to Erudite which will embrace her curiosity, or to Dauntless – the thrill seekers whose total freedom and abandonment has always pulled at her?
If you don't want to know what faction Beatrice chooses, stop reading now

A film version of Divergent is currently in the works, and if you have seen any of the released stills it is quite obvious what Beatrice chooses.  My favourite moment in Divergent is during the choosing ceremony when Beatrice has to choose her faction.  Will she perform the ultimate selfless act and prove herself worthy of Abnegation by staying solely to comfort her parents?  “I am selfish.  I am brave”.  Beatrice chooses Dauntless.

Tris' first look at the Dauntless compound

Life in Dauntless is not at all what she expected.  A new life deserves a new name, but unwilling to completely deny her previous life, Beatrice renames herself Tris.  Once inside the compound the new initiates learn a terrifying truth: Only the top ten initiates will ultimately become Dauntless, ten will become factionless, rejected from society and forced to live on the street.  Tris is by far the smallest initiate, physically her chances don’t look good.  Will her bravery be enough to secure a place in the top ten? 


Tris doing fight training during the first phase of initiation 

Tris’ choice to transfer to Dauntless is considered to be quite radical as Abnegation transfers to Dauntless are extremely rare – while not as hostile as the relationship between Abnegation and Erudite, Abnegation and Dauntless can’t seem to see eye to eye.  This complicates Tris’ new life even more.  Members and initiates of other factions are hostile towards Tris, especially the Dauntless born as they have little respect for the peaceful and selfless way of life of the Abnegation, which they interpret as weakness and cowardice.  The Dauntless provides the military defense for all the factions, and the Abnegation in turn do not approve of violence or weapons, as weapons (even when used in self-defense) are self-serving.

While Tris does make some friends among the transfer initiates, she is not secure in these friendships as her new friends alternate between exploiting what they know to be her weakness (her physical strength), and deeply resenting her strength (her mental strength) and progress.  When an unplanned encounter and test of bravery leads to Tris being the only transfer to befriend Dauntless born initiates and members alike, and enters the dining hall among Dauntless born who have obviously accepted her into their ranks, her fellow transfer initiates grow even more resentful and Tris soon finds herself in danger from friends and foes alike. 

Tris also forms an unlikely friendship with the transfer initiates’ instructor, Four, even though he seems to have just as much of a problem with her Abnegation roots as everyone else.  While they seem to have a connection, Four’s behaviour is unpredictable.  When he and Tris are alone he is unguarded, compliments her and gives her advice; in front of the other initiates, though, Four seems to be harder on Tris than any of the others.  Despite this, Tris can't help but react to him.  "Then I realise what it is. It's him.  Something about him makes me feel like I am about to fall.  Or turn to liquid. Or burst into flames".  Having spent her life in Abnegation, where couples don't even hold hands, Tris finds her attraction to Four confusing and unnerving.  Figuring out what exactly is going on between her and Four is, however, the least of Tris’ problems. 

Tris and Four

Abnegation, despite being peaceful, neutral, and calm, have a fierce ongoing rivalry with the Erudite.  Abnegation is the faction in charge of the Government, and the Erudite, who seek power, believe that Abnegation are in fact selfish people who only provide for their own faction.  When Erudite starts releasing reports heavily critising Abnegation, Tris seems to be the only one onto the seriousness of the matter.  She suspects that Erudite is planning to overthrow Government and destroy Abnegation.  But how can one lone, lowly initiate prove it?   And more importantly, how can she stop it?

Divergent by Veronica Roth is the first book in the Divergent Trilogy.  The second book, Insurgent is already available and Allegiant, the final book in the trilogy will be released in October 2013.


The Divergent trilogy has frequently been compared to Suzanne Collins’ The Hunger Games Trilogy.  Are they similar?  Yes.  Are they on the same level?  Not quite – in my humble opinion.  I enjoyed Divergent, but it doesn’t have the same pull or intensity that I experienced with The Hunger Games trilogy.  While I was reading I enjoyed it, but once I put the book down I never experienced the urge to get back to reading as soon as possible.  Don’t get me wrong, the book is not bad at all, and I look forward to the movie (which will be released in 2014) and I will definitely continue reading the series.  It’s just not the best YA series I’ve ever read.  Yet.  There is a lot of potential for this series and I look forward to continuing the story in Insurgent.  It is very possible that this series could turn out to be exceptional by the end.  

I really like Tris as a character.  While small, she is strong and brave.  Tris is an excellent protagonist for this story and the supporting characters are well drawn and diverse.  Four is also a very interesting character and the progression of their relationship is very natural and a pleasure to follow. 


The film version of Divergent has completed filming and will hit theatres March 2014.  Shailene Woodley has been cast as Tris and Theo James has been cast as Four.  Some big names have jumped on board with this one:  Kate Winslet is playing Erudite leader Jeanine Matthews, and Ashley Judd is playing Tris’ mother, Natalie.  Tris’ father is played by Tony Goldwyn and Tris’ tattoo artist and confidant, Tori, is played by Maggie Q.  An interesting Hunger Games connection is that ZoĆ« Kravitz, the daughter of Lenny Kravitz who plays Cinna in the film version of The Hunger Games, is playing Tris’ friend, Christina.  I very much look forward to the movie; if the released movie stills are anything to go by it will do the book absolute justice.

I almost loved it, but not quite

Product Information:
Title: Divergent
Author: Veronica Roth
Pages: 487
Publisher: HarperCollins
Year: 2011
ISBN:978-0-00-742042-1



Followers

Twitter

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...